Transcendence and Healing

The Scientific Account

A Revolution in Understanding

For much of the twentieth century, mainstream psychology viewed religion and spirituality with suspicion. Sigmund Freud famously dismissed religious belief as an "illusion" and a "universal obsessive neurosis." The assumption was that rational, secular thinking represented mental health, while faith represented a crutch for the weak.

The data told a different story.

Beginning in the 1980s and accelerating dramatically in recent decades, a flood of empirical research has revealed that the relationship between spirituality and mental health is far more complex—and far more positive—than the early skeptics assumed. Today, over 3,000 empirical studies have examined this relationship, and the findings are striking.

What the Research Shows

A comprehensive 2021 review in World Psychiatry examined the current state of evidence across numerous psychiatric conditions:

Depression: The strongest evidence exists here. Higher levels of religious involvement consistently correlate with lower rates of depression and faster recovery from depressive episodes.

Suicidality: Religious involvement is associated with significantly lower rates of suicide attempts and completed suicides, even controlling for other factors.

Substance Use: Strong evidence shows that religious and spiritual practices protect against substance abuse and support recovery.

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder: Spirituality and religiousness appear to buffer against post-traumatic stress, generally increasing psychological growth following traumatic experiences.

Anxiety: Religious beliefs that emphasize a loving, supportive God correlate with lower anxiety; beliefs emphasizing punishment show more mixed results.

The Self-Transcendence Factor

Perhaps the most illuminating line of research concerns self-transcendence—the psychological capacity to look beyond one's own self and connect with something greater.

Psychologist Pamela Reed defines self-transcendence as "expansion of self-conceptual boundaries inwardly through introspective activities, outwardly through concerns about others' welfare, and temporally through integration of the past and future." It is a personality trait, but one that can be cultivated.

Research distinguishes three types of transcendence:

1. Ego transcendence: Moving beyond self-preoccupation
2. Self-transcendence: Connection to others and the world
3. Spiritual transcendence: Connection to something beyond space and time

All three are associated with improved mental health outcomes, but spiritual transcendence appears particularly powerful in the face of severe adversity.

Why Transcendence Heals

A 2023 paper titled "Transcending the Self to Transcend Suffering" proposed several mechanisms:

Cognitive Reframing: Transcendent experiences provide new frameworks for understanding suffering. What seems meaningless becomes part of a larger story.

Emotional Regulation: The profound positivity of transcendent experiences—awe, wonder, connectedness—can supersede and diminish negative emotions.

Social Connection: Spiritual communities provide belonging, support, and a sense of being part of something larger than oneself.

Purpose and Meaning: Perhaps most importantly, transcendence provides a sense of purpose that extends beyond personal concerns.

The ego, when left to its own devices, faces an impossible task: it must find meaning in a universe that appears indifferent to its existence, and it must confront the certainty of its own death. These are burdens too heavy for the self alone to bear.

The Ego as Enemy

The ancient wisdom traditions have long warned that the ego—the small self that says "I" and "mine"—is both necessary and dangerous. Necessary because without it we could not function; dangerous because it tends to demand that the entire universe revolve around its needs.

Modern research suggests this insight has profound implications for mental health. Those who are trapped in excessive self-focus—ruminating about their problems, comparing themselves to others, measuring their worth by external standards—are at higher risk for depression, anxiety, and prolonged grief.

Conversely, those who can step outside the ego—through meditation, through service to others, through religious devotion, or through simple experiences of awe—tend to be more resilient, more content, and better able to weather life's storms.

Faith and the Fear of Death

No aspect of the ego's burden is heavier than the knowledge of mortality. Terror Management Theory, developed by social psychologists building on the work of Ernest Becker, proposes that much of human culture exists to manage the terror of death.

The relationship between religious belief and death anxiety is complex. Research consistently finds a U-shaped curve:

- Those with strong, consistent religious beliefs report the lowest death anxiety
- Those with no religious beliefs report moderate death anxiety
- Those who are moderately religious—uncertain in their beliefs—report the highest death anxiety

What matters most is not the content of belief but its consistency and depth. The person who genuinely believes in an afterlife has made peace with mortality in a way that transforms the meaning of death. The atheist who has genuinely accepted the finality of death has also made peace, through a different route. It is those caught in between—half-believing, half-doubting—who suffer most.

This finding illuminates why halfhearted religion provides little benefit. The ego cannot be transcended through lukewarm commitment. One must, as the traditions say, give oneself wholly.

Recent Advances (2024-2025)

The field continues to evolve rapidly. Recent research includes:

Neuroimaging Studies: Brain scans during prayer and meditation reveal distinct patterns of activity associated with transcendent experiences, lending biological credibility to subjective reports.

Integration in Clinical Practice: Psychiatry is increasingly recognizing that integrating spirituality into mental health care can foster deeper therapeutic connections and improved outcomes.

Pediatric Applications: Research on children and adolescents shows that religious involvement is associated with resilience after trauma, suggesting early spiritual development may be protective.

Cross-Cultural Confirmation: Studies across diverse cultural contexts confirm that the benefits of spiritual practice are not limited to Western Christianity but appear across religious traditions.

---

The Captain's Account

The Man Without a Star

The Captain has known many sailors in his years upon the waters. Most carry some faith, some star by which they navigate the inner seas. It may be the Christian God, the Islamic submission to Allah, the Jewish covenant, the Buddhist path, or simply a conviction that the universe has order and meaning.

But the Captain has also known men without any star at all. Men who believe in nothing but themselves—their own cleverness, their own strength, their own will to survive.

Such men can be capable. They can be successful, for a time. But the Captain has observed that when storms come—when the beloved wife dies, when the business fails, when the body begins to betray—these men have nowhere to turn. Their whole world was themselves, and when the self proves insufficient, there is nothing left.

What the Ego Cannot Do

The ego, the Captain has learned, cannot save itself. It is a necessary thing—one must have a self to sail a ship, to make decisions, to navigate the world. But the ego alone cannot provide:

Meaning in suffering. When the storms come, the ego asks only "Why me?" It has no larger story to tell.

Peace in mortality. The ego knows it will die, and this knowledge is unbearable to it. Every thought of death is a threat.

True connection. The ego relates to others only as extensions of itself or as obstacles to its desires. It cannot truly love, for love requires forgetting oneself.

Lasting contentment. The ego is a hungry ghost, always wanting more, never satisfied, comparing itself eternally to others.

The Gift of Something Greater

The Captain does not tell men which star to follow. That is not his office. But he has observed that men who follow some star—who believe in something greater than their own small selves—weather the storms better.

The Christian sailor who believes his suffering serves God's mysterious purpose can endure what would break the man who believes only in random chance.

The Buddhist sailor who has made peace with impermanence can release what the grasping ego cannot let go.

The sailor who believes in nothing supernatural but serves some cause greater than himself—justice, truth, his fellow man—has something to live for beyond his own survival.

The Captain himself? He has his beliefs, but he keeps them close. What he shares freely is this observation: the size of your world determines the size of your suffering.

If your world is only yourself, every loss is total, every threat is existential, every slight is unbearable.

If your world includes something greater—whether you call it God, dharma, the Tao, the good of humanity, or simply the mystery of existence—then your losses, however painful, are not the end of meaning. There is something that continues when you stop.

On Death

The Captain has seen men die—at sea, in port, in beds and in battles. He has observed that those who believe in something beyond themselves tend to die more peacefully. They are going somewhere, or returning somewhere, or becoming part of something. Death is a transition, not an annihilation.

Those who worshipped only their own ego face death as utter extinction. Everything they were, everything they built, everything they loved—gone, as if it never existed. This is a hard death, and the Captain has seen it make strong men weep with terror.

The Captain does not claim to know what happens after the body fails. But he knows what happens before it fails, and here the evidence is clear: those who have found something greater than themselves die with more peace and live with more purpose.

A Practical Truth

This is not a theological argument. The Captain is a sailor, not a priest. It is a practical observation, confirmed now by the science of the shore:

The soul needs moorings.

A ship needs anchor and harbor. A soul needs something beyond itself to which it can belong. Call it faith, call it purpose, call it community, call it the mystery—but call it something. The ego alone is not enough to sustain a human life through all its storms.

The scientists have measured this now, with their surveys and their brain scans. They have found what the sailors always knew: we are made for transcendence. We sicken without it. We heal through it.

Find your star, then. Whichever one calls to you. But do not sail without one. The sea is too vast and too dark for a ship that has no destination beyond itself.

---

References

Bonelli, R. M., & Koenig, H. G. (2013). Mental disorders, religion and spirituality 1990 to 2010: A systematic evidence-based review. Journal of Religion and Health, 52(2), 657-673. PMC

Frankl, V. E. (1959). Man's Search for Meaning. Beacon Press.

Hanfstingl, B. (2013). Ego and spiritual transcendence: Relevance to psychological resilience and the role of age. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2013, 949838. PMC

Jong, J., & Halberstadt, J. (2020). Death anxiety and religion. Current Opinion in Psychology, 40, 40-44. ScienceDirect

Koenig, H. G. (2009). Research on religion, spirituality, and mental health: A review. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 54(5), 283-291. PMC

Moreira-Almeida, A., Sharma, A., van Rensburg, B. J., Verhagen, P. J., & Hefti, R. (2016). WPA position statement on spirituality and religion in psychiatry. World Psychiatry, 15(1), 87-88.

Reed, P. G. (1991). Self-transcendence and mental health in oldest-old adults. Nursing Research, 40(1), 5-11. Self-Transcendence Theory

Schnell, T. (2023). Transcending the self to transcend suffering. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1157545. PMC

Unterrainer, H. F., Lewis, A. J., & Fink, A. (2014). Religious/spiritual well-being, personality and mental health: A review of results and conceptual issues. Journal of Religion and Health, 53(2), 382-392.

Yaden, D. B., Haidt, J., Hood, R. W., Vago, D. R., & Newberg, A. B. (2017). The varieties of self-transcendent experience. Review of General Psychology, 21(2), 143-160. SAGE Journals